Best Dinner in Umatilla: Hearty Homestyle Meals Done Right
Best Dinner in Umatilla: Hearty Homestyle Meals Done Right
Dinner should feel like coming home, not settling for leftovers. At The Mason Jar in Umatilla, Florida, we believe every evening meal deserves attention, warmth, and a full belly. That’s why locals say we serve the best dinner in Umatilla with hearty portions, made-from-scratch recipes, and that unmistakable feeling of being taken care of.
Whether you’re wrapping up a long workday, treating the family to a night out, or meeting friends for a comfort-filled catch-up, we’ve got your seat ready and your plate waiting.
What’s for Dinner? A Menu That’s Made to Satisfy
The Mason Jar’s dinner menu is built around what comfort food done right is all about: real ingredients, real portions, and real flavor.
Some of our most popular evening plates include:
Homestyle Meatloaf – Tender, flavorful, and topped with rich brown gravy. Served with your favorite sides.
Country Fried Steak – Crispy, golden perfection covered in creamy white gravy.
Roast Beef & Gravy – A tender slow-cooked meal served all week long.
Homemade Chicken & Dumplings – Warm, hearty, and loaded with love.
Fried Chicken Thursdays – Only available once a week, and folks plan their week around it.
We also offer fresh salads, burgers, and sandwiches for those wanting something a little lighter but still full of flavor.
One of the Most Trusted Restaurants Open for Dinner in Umatilla
What sets The Mason Jar apart from other restaurants open for dinner in Umatilla is simple: we take pride in what we serve and who we serve it to. Every dish that leaves our kitchen has been made with care, by cooks who understand tradition and with service that feels like a warm hug.
No shortcuts. Just honest-to-goodness meals, made from scratch.
We’re proud to welcome:
Families gathering around the table after ball practice
Retirees looking for a peaceful and fulfilling meal
Guests from nearby towns seeking a no-fuss, high-quality dinner
And if you’re in a hurry or just want a cozy meal at home, our takeout dinners come packed with the same care and quality.
What Locals Say About Dinner at The Mason Jar
Nothing makes us prouder than hearing what our guests have to say about their dinner experience with us.
“Dinner at The Mason Jar is like Sunday supper any day of the week. The portions are huge and the food is always on point.” — Barbara T., Umatilla
“My wife and I eat here at least twice a week. The fried chicken on Thursdays is a can't-miss. We love that it's always consistent and delicious.” — Ron D., Altoona
“It’s rare to find a restaurant that feels this welcoming at dinnertime. The service, the food, the atmosphere, it’s all just right.” — Michelle W., Eustis
A Perfect Evening Stop in the Heart of Umatilla
Whether you’re coming from a day at Lake Umatilla, finishing a shift at work, or winding down from a walk in Ocala National Forest, The Mason Jar is your go-to dinner destination.
We’re centrally located and easy to get to, with plenty of parking and seating even on busy nights. And with our daily dinner specials, you’ll always have something new (and comforting) to look forward to.
View Our Full Menu and Make It a Mason Jar Night
Curious about what’s for dinner tonight?
View our full menu here: Menus | The Mason Jar in Umatilla, FL
Location:37534 SR-19, Umatilla, FL 32784
Hours: Tuesday–Sunday: 6:00 AM – 8:00 PM Sunday: 6:00 AM – 2:00 PM
(Yes, we’re open for dinner Tuesday through Sunday!)
Comfort Food, Community, and the Best Dinner in Umatilla
At The Mason Jar, dinner is more than just another meal. It’s a chance to slow down, reconnect, and enjoy food the way it was meant to be: warm, welcoming, and made with love.
Stop by tonight and see why so many say we serve the best dinner in Umatilla. Bring your appetite, bring your people, and leave with a full heart (and maybe some leftovers for tomorrow).